KEY WEST DINE AROUND
From fresh hook & cook seafood and elegant waterfront dinners to hidden gems with plenty of Key West personality, the island serves up incredible fare. Beyond the Casa Marina and The Reach venues, we’ve curated a list of local restaurants that may work well for group reservations. Consider this your starting point for planning memorable meals without searching the entire island from scratch.
Many Key West restaurants are located in small historic buildings, so seating larger parties can take some planning. The restaurants below are good options for groups of seven or more. Make reservations early and call the restaurant directly when your party size is not available online.
EASY GROUP DINING OPTIONS
SEVEN FISH
921 Truman Ave., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-296-2777
Polished casual dining for dinner. Seven Fish is known for fresh seafood and creative island dishes served in a contemporary bistro setting. Its private Blue Water Room can accommodate groups of up to 40, making this one of the strongest options for a larger dinner. Reservations are strongly recommended.
SANTIAGO’S BODEGA
207 Petronia St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-296-7691
Casual tapas-style dining for lunch or dinner. Sharing small plates makes Santiago’s an especially fun choice for groups that like to try a little of everything. The restaurant is intimate, so reserve early and use its large-party inquiry option for bigger groups.
LOUIE’S BACKYARD
700 Waddell Ave., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-294-1061
Fine dining for lunch, brunch or dinner. Louie’s offers an upscale oceanfront meal just a short distance from Casa Marina. It is an excellent choice for a special dinner, but the restaurant can accommodate no more than 12 people. Reservations must be made by phone, and you can only make them two months in advance.
SALUTE! ON THE BEACH
1000 Atlantic Blvd., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-292-1117
Casual beachfront dining for breakfast, lunch or dinner. Salute serves seafood, pasta, sandwiches and other approachable options in a relaxed setting on Higgs Beach. Larger groups should reserve early or contact the restaurant directly about group seating.
FIRST FLIGHT ISLAND RESTAURANT & BREWERY
301 Whitehead St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-293-8484
Casual dining for lunch or dinner. Located in the historic birthplace of Pan American World Airways, First Flight offers house-brewed beer, a broad menu and spacious garden seating. Its size and variety make it a particularly good choice for larger groups with mixed tastes.
BAGATELLE
115 Duval St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-296-6609
Upscale casual dining for brunch or dinner. Bagatelle serves seafood, steaks and creative island dishes in a historic home near Mallory Square. Private and semi-private spaces are available for groups large and small, including the upper floor and balcony overlooking Duval Street.
A&B LOBSTER HOUSE
700 Front St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-294-5880
Fine dining for dinner. A&B Lobster House offers seafood, lobster and steaks in a polished waterfront setting overlooking the marina. Its private dining room can accommodate up to 18 guests, making it a strong option for an executive or business dinner.
EL MESON DE PEPE
410 Wall St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-295-2620
Casual Cuban dining for lunch or dinner. Located at Mallory Square, El Mesón de Pepe combines traditional Cuban food, mojitos and live music in a lively setting. Regular dining is first come, first served, so larger groups should contact the restaurant about private-party or group arrangements.
CONCH REPUBLIC SEAFOOD COMPANY
631 Greene St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-294-4403
Casual waterfront dining for lunch or dinner. This large, open-air restaurant at the historic seaport serves seafood and Caribbean-inspired dishes in a lively marina setting. It is one of the safest choices for a genuinely large casual group, with event spaces that can seat 30 to 200 guests.
MANGOES
700 Duval St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-294-8002
Casual Caribbean dining for lunch or dinner. Mangoes offers seafood, tropical dishes, cocktails and live entertainment in the middle of Duval Street. The restaurant regularly handles groups ranging from six to 300, making it one of the most flexible options on this list.
SOUTHERNMOST BEACH CAFE
1405 Duval St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-295-6550
Casual oceanfront dining for breakfast, lunch or dinner. Southernmost Beach Café serves seafood, island-style breakfast dishes and approachable American fare with a view of the Atlantic. Its location near Casa Marina makes it a convenient scenic option, although larger groups should contact the restaurant or resort directly.
TOP KEY WEST FAVORITES FOR SMALLER TABLES
You may already have a few must-visit restaurants on your Key West list. For the unclaimed spots on your schedule, these standout establishments are worth considering for a quieter dinner, a table for two and a memorable meal.
BLUE HEAVEN
729 Thomas St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-296-8666
Casual outdoor dining for breakfast, lunch or dinner. Blue Heaven makes the list because it is both a restaurant and a full-blown Key West experience, with tropical gardens, live music and roaming chickens in historic Bahama Village. This Key West staple received Tripadvisor’s 2025 Best of the Best recognition and a Michelin Guide distinction for good cooking. The wait can be substantial, especially at breakfast.
GARBO’S GRILL
409 Caroline St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-304-3004
Very casual food-truck dining for lunch, dinner or a late-night meal. Garbo’s proves that one of the island’s best meals does not require white tablecloths or a reservation. Located at Hank’s Saloon with outdoor seating and live music, it delivers excellent food without sanding off the wonderfully weird Key West edges.
RED SHOE ISLAND BISTRO
411 Petronia St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-509-7271
Intimate, upscale dining for dinner. Guests repeatedly praise the seafood, personal service and desserts, especially the key lime pie and lavender cheesecake. Reservations are essential.
LITTLE PEARL
632 Olivia St., Key West, FL 33040 | 305-204-4762
Fine dining for dinner. Little Pearl offers a four-course chef’s tasting menu built around local seafood and creative flavor combinations. This is the pick for someone who wants the meal itself to be the evening’s main event.
THANK YOU TO OUR SPONSORS
